Why AI in UX Is Not Really All It's Cracked Up to Be
AI in UX: Critical Thinking, Synthetic Users, and the Risk of Blind Trust
• The conversation between Jen of BlatzChatz and Sarah Doody explores concerns about people blindly trusting AI outputs.
• Sarah compares it to the spread of fake news.
• She emphasizes the need to vet AI-generated information.
• Sarah describes AI as a helpful thought partner that can speed up UX work — especially research analysis and synthesizing data across sources.
• But she warns it’s only as good as the inputs and can erode critical thinking if users outsource judgment.
• The discussion critiques “synthetic users,” arguing UX research and usability testing require real people, relationships and contextual cues like body language that AI can’t replicate.
• AI has the tendency to be overly pleasing.
• Sarah also highlight risks like analysis paralysis, inaccuracies and hallucinations (e.g., fabricated work histories or misquoted interviews).
• AI should be treated like an intern whose work must be double-checked.
Sarah Doody is a UX Researcher & Product Designer with 22 years of experience. She is also the founder and CEO of Career Strategy Lab, a UX job search and career coaching program where she helps UX and product people get hired or promoted with average 5-figure salary increases. She is also the host of the podcast, Career Strategy Podcast that offers weekly tips and case studies about what’s working in the UX job market and hiring right now. Sarah also speaks at conferences worldwide including UXLX, UX London, AIGA, Productized, Front, Industry, and more.
Find More About Sarah
Career Strategy Lab: www.careerstrategylab.com
Sarah's personal website: www.sarahdoody.com
Connect with Sarah on LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/sarahdoody
Watch Sarah's Youtube: / sarahdoody
Career Strategy Podcast: www.careerstrategylab.com/podcasts
Do you want to see more conversations with industry pros? Check out more from this playlist: • Conversations: Chatz with Industry Pros on...
👉 Sign up for the BlatzChatz Newsletter: https://blatzchatz.beehiiv.com/subscribe
⏰ Timestamps
00:00 Blind Trust and Fake News
00:35 AI as a UX Thought Partner
01:30 Critical Thinking and Prompt Quality
03:47 Synthetic Users Debate
05:48 Why Real Research Matters
07:22 AI Speeds Analysis Not Replacing Jobs
09:19 Analysis Paralysis and Accuracy Checks
10:14 Treat AI Like an Intern
👉 Sign up for the BlatzChatz Newsletter: https://blatzchatz.beehiiv.com/subscribe
The good, the trendy and the downright ugly in UX, product and tech.
😎 Follow BlatzChatz on social media
LinkedIn / blatzchatz
Instagram / blatzchatz
Twitter X / blatzchatz
Medium / jnblatz
Website https://blatzchatz.com
#BlatzChatz #UXBestPractices #UXResearch #UXR #UX #UserExperience