Unpopular Opinion: Alliser Thorne Is Not All Bad And Loyal

Опубликовано: 30 Сентябрь 2026
на канале: Binge Buddha
978
21

Why Aegon Used Swords To Build The Iron Throne? And More You Didn't Know About Aegon's Seat Of Power
   • Why Aegon Used Swords To Build The Iron Th...  

Who Will Be Drogon's New Rider After Daenerys? 4 Possible Contenders Explored
   • Who Will Be Drogon's New Rider After Daene...  

All [5] Theories Behind Daenerys' Return and Resurrection Explored-- What We Just Found Out
   • All [5] Theories Behind Daenerys' Return a...  

Lady Catelyn Stark's Dark And Tragic Fate Explored, Did She Become Zombie Like In The Book?
   • Lady Catelyn Stark's Dark And Tragic Fate ...  

All Valyrian Steel Swords Ever
   • All  Valyrian Steel Swords Ever  

All Targaryen Rulers Ever
   • All Targaryen Rulers Ever  

All (60) Major Differences Between House of the Dragon and The Book (Fire and Blood)
   • All (60) Major Differences Between House o...  

How Did Aegon Conquer The Seven Kingdoms? His Reign and Family History Explored
   • How Did Aegon Conquer The Seven Kingdoms? ...  

All Dragons That Would Survive The Dance of Dragon in House of the Dragon
   • All Dragons That Would Survive The Dance o...  

The Complete History of Westeros and Essos Until Dance of Dragons
   • The Complete History of Westeros and Essos...  

Top 11 Great Houses of Westeros, Ranked
   • Top 11 Great Houses of Westeros, Ranked  


In the intricate world of Game of Thrones, characters often fall into distinct categories of hero or villain, their moral compass guiding their every action. However, one character challenges this simplistic view, often presenting himself in the grey area. He's the star of today's show, Ser Alliser Thorne. In this video we will delve deeper the complex circumstances that shaped his character. From his noble background to his tumultuous experiences beyond the Wall, we will explore the reasons behind Ser Alliser's animosity towards Jon Snow and the recruits of the Night's Watch. Additionally, we will explore the moments that exhibit his honor, duty, and the sacrifices he made for what he believed was the greater good, irrespective of the consequences such actions bore.

1. Why Is Alliser Thorne So Mean?
Ser Alliser Thorne was the stern, no-nonsense guy of the Night's Watch.
And of course, he's not exactly Mr. Sunshine and Rainbows, but let's give credit where it's due. Despite his grumpy exterior, he's not inherently evil or out to be a total jerkwad. So, why the constant beef with Jon Snow and the other recruits? Well, it seems to stem from his noble background and his disdain for how the Night's Watch has become a dumping ground for criminals. Furthermore, House Thorne was pledged to the Targaryens, but Robert's rebellion led to the fall of the dynasty. And it was Ned Stark who played a major role in bringing down the Targaryen empire. Following this, Thorne was sent atop the wall. So yes, there's some serious bad blood there. On top of all that, Thorne's had a traumatizing experience beyond the Wall. It's enough to make anyone a little grumpy. So when he's in charge of training new recruits he is anything but kind. Just ask poor Samwell Tarly, who got the special treatment in the courtyard.

But Is There Any Silver Lining?
There's a glimmer of decency in there somewhere! Despite his flaws, Thorne's actually dedicated to protecting the Wall and the Seven Kingdoms. He may do some questionable things in the process, like killing a Lord Commander every once in a while, but hey, he doesn’t do it out of malice. He truly believes in his cause. Thorne's got mad respect for Maester Aemon and Qhorin Halfhand, even admitting to Jon that he considered Qhorin, a brother. Furthermore, when it's battle time, Thorne doesn't shy away. He leads the Night's Watch into the thick of things, facing off against wildlings and even going one-on-one with Tormund Giantsbane. That takes some serious cojones, my friends. Before the big showdown, he even has a heart-to-heart with Jon, sharing some leadership wisdom and trying to boost his morale. It's like a gruff version of a pep talk. So, Alliser Thorne may not be the poster child for sunshine and rainbows, but he didn’t kill Gilly and the baby, despite his deep hatred for the Wildlings. Yes, he was never sweet to her, but in his own way, he ensured their safety.

The Real Reason Why Thorne Planned The Assassination of Jon
Thorne is a guy who's willing to do whatever it takes to protect the realm.
And in his grumpy eyes, Jon committed the ultimate betrayal by letting the wildlings pass through the Wall. You see, keeping those wildlings out was like the Night's Watch's whole raison d'être. It was the reason they shed blood, sweat, and tears (and probably a fair amount of frostbite). So when Jon pulls a backflip and welcomes the wildlings with open arms to save them from the icy wrath of the White Walkers, Thorne's head practically explodes. In his eyes, Jon just broke the sacred trust and spat on the graves of their fallen comrades.