A Debate on Immigration, Ethnostates, and National Identity
This week, Noah Smith talks to Erik Torenberg about his viral post on land acknowledgements, exploring how nations should be defined by institutions rather than ethnic identity. The conversation expands into a discussion of immigration, cultural assimilation, and sovereignty across countries like Israel, Japan, South Korea, and Botswana, examining how different nations navigate the balance between cultural preservation and integration. For full show notes, visit: https://highlightai.com/share/b7f9f1c...
--
📰Be notified early when Turpentine drops new publication: https://www.turpentine.co/exclusiveac...
--
SPONSORS:
GiveWell
GiveWell spends 50,000 hours every year doing deep-dives into different charitable programs to try to find the ways to do the most good for your dollar. GiveWell has now spent over 17 years researching charitable organizations and only directs funding to a few of the HIGHEST-IMPACT opportunities they’ve found. Visit https://www.givewell.org to find out more or make a donation. Select PODCAST and enter Econ 102 at checkout to make sure they know you heard about them from us.
NetSuite
More than 40,000 businesses have already upgraded to NetSuite by Oracle, the #1 cloud financial system bringing accounting, financial management, inventory, HR, into ONE proven platform. Download the CFO's Guide to AI and Machine learning: https://netsuite.com/102
📑 Discover Carta, the innovative end-to-end accounting platform revolutionizing private fund management with streamlined operations and on-demand insights. Experience the new standard at https://carta.com/investors/
--
SEND US YOUR Q's FOR NOAH TO ANSWER ON AIR: [email protected]
--
FOLLOW ON X:
@noahpinion
@eriktorenberg
@turpentinemedia
--
LINKS:
Noahpinion: https://www.noahpinion.blog/
No, you are not on Indigenous land: https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/no-you-...
--
TIMESTAMPS:
(00:00) Intro
(00:40) Erik’s meditation retreat and Noah’s Thanksgiving
(01:10) Global events recap: South Korea’s coup, Syrian rebels, and Kash Patel’s FBI nomination
(02:30) Viral PhD thesis on exclusion and "stinkiness"
(03:50) Overproduction of PhDs and the politicization of academia
(05:00) Noah’s Thanksgiving Substack post on land rights and ethno-nationalism
(07:00) Critique of land declarations and racial ownership of land
(08:40) Israel as a theocracy vs. ethno-state
(11:00) Historical examples of ethno-nationalism and its consequences
(14:30) The U.S. as an institutional nation-state
(16:30) Israel’s demographic shifts and the rise of the ultra-Orthodox
(18:00) Theocracy vs. ethno-state: Key distinctions
(20:00) The risks of global governance and the importance of experimentation
(24:00) America’s superpower: Assimilation of immigrants
(26:00) Japan’s immigration policies and lessons on cultural assimilation
(33:00) The role of language in national identity
(39:00) Hypothetical scenarios: Immigration and demographic shifts in Botswana
(43:00) Ethno-nationalism’s tendency toward violence and exclusion
(47:00) The limits of global governance: Stability vs. conformity
(50:00) U.S. linguistic identity and the decline of Spanish over generations
(55:00) Demographics and the future of global population shifts
(58:00) The balance between nation-states and mini ethno-states
(01:02:00) Israel’s land policies and the decline of moderate positions
(01:03:50) Closing thoughts: Sovereignty, ethno-states, and global politics