The Andromeda Strain - Original vs Remake

Опубликовано: 24 Март 2026
на канале: John Chang
5,159
19

How does the original vs remake of The Andromeda Strain compare? This week we look at this classic thriller based on Michael Crichton's novel.


SPOILER ALERT - there will be plot elements related to the endings for both movies. If you haven't seen them, go watch them now.

Where to watch Andromeda Strain (current as of 04/27/20) -

1971 - https://hdfy.to/movies/sci-fi/the-and...

2008 - https://hdfy.to/tv-shows/action/the-a...

Want to know how to watch Andromeda Strain and other great movies?

Try HDFY for free and watch thousands of hit movies, plus your favorite TV shows.. You can even show your support for this program - https://m.me/jycmba (request your free trial link good for 24 hr)


“Show Notes”:

0:00:32 - will current pandemic cause us to move back to smaller towns

0:03:06 - how will local businesses survive vs big corporations

0:05:04 - what work from home / co-working spaces will

0:07:08 - changes yet to come after Covid19

What is the Andromeda Strain?



0:09:10 - original Andromeda Strain groundbreaking techno thriller

0:10:20 - how Michael Crichton found his niche combining science and storytelling

0:13:02 - made up citations in the novel that seemed real enough to screenwriter

0:14:20 - l-o-n-g decontamination process combined with weird effects

0:15:50 - life imitating art, e.g. personnel in hazmat suits

0:17:42 - how horror vs thrillers differ - race against time

0:19:30 - what Robert Wise does to keep tension despite minimalist plot

0:20:36 - why choice of woman as one of scientists was so effective

0:22:12 - again tactical nuke considered option

0:23:50 - cardboard generated “CGI” - aka practical effects


0:25:20 - portraying advanced technology that become reality over time, e.g. Star Tre

0:28:06 - why did our government develop internet

0:28:52 ** short break **

0:28:06 - how does Andromeda Strain remake compare to original

0:30:24 - why expectations were high with Ridley Scott producing

0:32:02 - top sin of remakes is overexplaining with dialogue - especially tv movies

0:33:48 - bad use of good actors like Daniel Dae Kim and Viola Davis

0:35:02 - cringeworthy performances that were shown repeatedly

0:36:28 - remake vs original portraying urgency of crisis

0:37:38 - portrayal of military had some accuracy


0:38:26 - why portraying female pilot failed in remake

0:40:24 - how remakes fail with “less is more” e.g. explaining virus with wormholes??

0:42:30 - good ideas with bad execution, i.e. dramatic toss of Ricky Shroeder’s thumb

0:44:20 - Birdemic schlock vs how original portrayed killing lab animals

0:45:50 - soap opera dramatics during a global crisis

0:47:20 - mistrust between different groups

0:48:32 - how human error is often used as story device by Michael Crichton

0:49:40 - classic sci-fi theme of man reaching a bit too far, e.g. Icarus effect

0:50:50 - original vs remake - alien life vs. environmental theme

0:52:10 - why environmental theme was lost in remake

0:54:06 - typical use of conspiracy with NSA thrown in pre- Edward Snowden

0:55:32 - 28 Days Later rip-off scenes was another example of combining too many things

0:56:50 - ultimately characters’ attempts almost did more harm than good

0:58:52 - coming up: revisiting Westworld and rise of Michael Crichton’s career

1:00:06 - writing novels for big screen vs novelization of movies



1:02:40 - Futureworld and Beyond Westworld tv series - canon vs non-canon